Tuesday, February 15, 2022

Despite The Correct Verdict in the Palin v. NYT Case. There Was Media Malpractice.


 


In the reporting about the case.   Various media outlets have been ignoring the important fact that yesterday, when the judge announced he would dismiss the case no matter what the jury said, he was granting the NYT's motion to dismiss, which was filed before the case went to the jury.  And now there is this conspiracy theory floating around out there that the judge went rogue.  Shit.  Even in the NYT's own story yesterday, they buried the fact the judge granted their motion, further down the article.

And  as is often the case, people don't fucking read the whole fucking story, or do not post the critical detail.  I am looking at you ex law professor Ann.  You got a bunch of your deplorables on your blog spewing all sorts of idiotic bullshit.  Even if one of the denizens there took the time to explain Fed.R.Civ.Pro. 50. And even if today we found out the jury, who were left alone to finished deliberating, as the judge thought their verdict would be of use to the 2nd Cir.  expected to have to handle the expected appeal? They unanimously found against the whiny assed, violent rhetoric spewing, poses with guns, snowbilly.  

So there.

I do not know how good this case is going to be for the desired goal of her financers, to overturn the landmark case that established the high burden for proving defamation if one is a public figure.  I would guess the fact the jury did not at all buy her weak assed, bullshit, whiny baby, baseless  claims?   That will make it harder for SCOTUS to even go there. So we are going to have to see.  The current rogue SCOTUS is hard to predict.  But I  have no reason to believe that there are enough votes on SCOTUS to grant review, never mind change the law in a way that is all but guaranteed to bankrupt Fox News, it's imitators, and basically all known conservative/right wing media.

Speaking of ex law professor Ann.  Here is the smartest comment on her blog by her denizens, at least before I started my post here:  

"The chance of a New York jury finding for Sarah Palin is about the same as Stalin's advisors telling him that Trotsky would have made a better leader."

So they are not all fucking morons, over there.




Labels: , , ,

Monday, February 14, 2022

Since I mentioned Gibson's v. Oberlin

 I am truly of the mind that merely being called a racist is not suitable grounds for a defamation action.  I might have said that before, when the case was hot.  These days it is considered a long, overdue ruling, by the appeals court.  Even if one of the judges on the original panel lost an election and the newbie needed time to  catch up on not only that case, but all she was assigned to, after winning the seat.  

Way I was arguing it to myself, and none of this is at all original.  Let's be honest.  It there ever really was any sting to the charge, that is no longer the case.  Not for grown ups, at least.  It's basically one of the random, go-to, easily used insults of the age.  It's on the level of being called  an asshole, actually.  It's name calling.  Pure and simple.  At its most common and base usage.  If the charge is in context with real specific wrong doing like accusing some elected or appointed official, judge, hospital administrator, teacher, whatever of engaging in a racially discriminatory pattern or racist  misuse of office?  That's different.  Context matters.  But, and to use an even better point of comparison. Merely  calling some rando a racist is like calling them a motherfucker.  There could be belief in the literal insult, but the charge more often than not is meant mostly if not exclusively as an insult. 

Now the problem in the Gibson's v. Oberlin matter is that Ohio is behind the times in knowing what time it is.  To employ a colloquial phrase.  Across the borderline, in Illinois, their courts recognize the plain and obvious truth that:

"Accusations of “racism” no longer are “obviously and naturally harmful.” The word has been watered down by overuse, becoming common coin in political discourse. Tillman called Stevens a racist; Stevens issued a press release calling Tillman a “racist” and her supporters “bigots.” … When Stevens called Tillman a “racist,” Stevens was accusing Tillman of playing racial politics … rather than of believing in segregation or racial superiority. That may be an unfortunate brand of politics, but it also drains the term of its former, decidedly opprobrious, meaning. … The term has acquired intermediate meanings too. The speaker may use “she is a racist” to mean “she is condescending to me, which must be because of my race because there is no other reason to condescend.” … Meanings of this sort fit comfortably within the immunity for name-calling. … In daily life “racist” is hurled about so indiscriminately that it is no more than a verbal slap in the face; the target can slap back (as Stevens did). It is not actionable unless it implies the existence of undisclosed, defamatory facts, and Stevens has not relied on any such implication."


And:

Similarly, in Grutzmacher v. Chicago Sun-Times Inc.,[3] Judge Kathy Flanagan, citing Stevens, found that statements referring to the plaintiff as a “neo-Nazi” were nonactionable opinions.

Stevens and Gruzmacher are based upon a fundamental concept in defamation law: To prove actionable, a statement must consist of objectively verifiable fact. Amorphous opinions, even when obviously negative, which lack clearly ascertainable meaning are not actionable.

Other Illinois reported cases have found that the following terms and phrases, in the absence of objectively verifiable facts, were nonactionable opinions: “fired because of incompetence,” “cocky con-artist,” “useless piece of shit,” “very poor lawyer,” “unethical,” “lazy,” “burnt out,” and “unstable.”

(Source)

I found that quote looking for the actual metrics about how many states do recognize this reality in their defamation law. I really think this needs to be the case, nationwide.  

Notable of the errors in the Gibson's v. Oberlin case is that the court not only did not require the plaintiff to carry the burden of proof and persuasion with evidence they were not in fact racists.  The judge actually kept evidence of racist animus on the part of the person who's action triggered the case, away from the jury.  Fucked up  and bullshit!   

Someone called you a racist?  Grow the fuck up! No payday for you! 




Labels: , ,

Re that violence loving, gun toting, helicopter hunting approving sno billy grifter's (my opinion) law suit,

 And calls for the "actual malice" standard to be revised in defamation actions?   Talk about people setting themselves up for being hoisted on their own petards?  And I mean the right wing lunatics who want that?

I do not want that, let me say up front.  But can you imagine any well known conservative media provider lasting in business for more than five years if the standard gets lowered for proving defamation of a public official or figure?   FNC  will get buried.  The even more lunatic copycats will be wiped off the map.  No insurance company will cover that exposure.  And if the law gets changed, following a Supreme Court rewrite and ruling?  Even given the one year statute of limitations  in many states, I have to predict a crippling onset of cases.   One of the reasons FNC gets away with so much over the top, flat out hateful shit is the  "actual malice" standard.  Granted, that Dominion lawsuit against them is a fairly dangerous threat to FNC.  And then there is Col. Vindman's.  So FNC has a good deal of exposure already.

I mean sure. I want them crushed.  But I think we are better off with the "actual malice" standard still in play.  Historically  judges disfavor defamation cases.  I should know.  I got my ass kicked pursuing a very good one.  Anyway

Last thoughts.  Palin is so associated with violent rhetoric that her case should have been dismissed, as it was, had been.  And her targeting map was so inflammatory that it is a reasonable interpretation that she was solicitating violence against her political party's opponents.  Far as I know, the reason for the overturning of the dismissal on appeal was even if technically within law.  It could have called harmless error, as on it's face  the pleading did not meet the necessary level for a prima facie case where "actual malice" cold have been proven, particularly how quickly the NYT  corrected the story.  And her claim of damages is fatuous.  She is the harpy who is famous for calling the "mainstream"  media  the "lamestream" media.  People who read and identify with the views of as she calls them the "lamestream" media tend to despise her already.

No real harm.  No provable damages.

Nota Bene:  I am still anticipating the result of the appeal of the Oberlin College case.  It is weird but not surprising that in some US states being called a racist is not considered actionable as defamation, but not all, as it should be.  But as we are now living in the anti anti racist times, and as I really don't know shit about the appellate courts in Ohio?  I can't really say there is hope for them to adopt that as the standard, going forward.  It is so hard to predict shit.  But at minimum, the damages were bullshit.  And in my understating of shit. The judge fucked up multiple times pre and during the trial. Most notably, fucked up in not dismissing  this shit.  That case was mostly some town vs gown treasure hunt. It might not be a rule of jurisprudence, but call shit as it looks!




Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, July 05, 2011

Fox News Calls on Wing Nut Shrink to Analyze Its "Enemy" . . .

such wing nut shrink making comments about the motives of the "Enemy."

I think the shrink would have been better off analyzing Fox's dysfunction in tapping him to attack its "enemy."

Irony get's lost on these wingnuts. Or common sense.

Here.

If I understood the law better, I might be willing to say David Brock of Media Matters has a good cause of action against Fox. But I know the law of defamation well enough to know that Fox would claim David Brock is a Public Person. And that all by itself makes the case less viable. Or at least more expensive. However . . . if David Brock can do some fundraising to fund the fight, he very well might get deep enough into discovery to find even more evidence to prove Fox is a nasty as he says it is. In theory I think proving actual malice is not so off the charts here that the case should not be allowed to go to depositions. That would just cost a lot of money to get that far.

If he chooses that path, good luck with that, I'd say. I likely could not work on such a case. I'm marginally conflicted out of that case on that side. Damnit!


PS: I know Fox could countersue. It could get ugly, in theory. Yea, in theory.

Labels: , , ,

Add to Technorati Favorites